Re: Season 4 Top Players

Thu May 19 2016, 17:15 Message reputation : 30% (10 votes)

This thread is almost useless. All this arbitrary XP nonsene and yet we still don't have a proper topscorer/assister table

Thu May 19 2016, 18:16 Message reputation : 78% (9 votes)

SebastiAn wrote:This thread is almost useless. All this arbitrary XP nonsene and yet we still don't have a proper topscorer/assister table

It takes 3 seconds to scroll down a bit and see who has the most goals/assists. Doing these stats is really a thankless job; Sugar has made an actually interesting system of comparing GK's and Strikers as well as the goals/assists being there. If you want it in a table format then why don't you do it yourself?

Thu May 19 2016, 18:33 Message reputation : 100% (3 votes)

yeah fuck off and kill yourself radu

Thu May 19 2016, 18:33

sorry lost it

Thu May 19 2016, 18:39 Message reputation : 0% (3 votes)

Why would I do it myself since he's already at it and doing it wrong? And it takes far more than 3 seconds to see the goalscorers sorted in that order and not by "XP".

And no, the system is definitely not interesting when his grading equals a clean sheet with the effort of scoring a hattrick, more so deciding that only one player is to be given credit for the clean sheet.

Yeah, cheers Jai. Really impressive

Thu May 19 2016, 18:50 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

SebastiAn wrote:Why would I do it myself since he's already at it and doing it wrong? And it takes far more than 3 seconds to see the goalscorers sorted in that order and not by "XP".

And no, the system is definitely not interesting when his grading equals a clean sheet with the effort of scoring a hattrick, more so deciding that only one player is to be given credit for the clean sheet.

Yeah, cheers Jai. Really impressive

You can pretty much see who is in the top 5/10 without much effort, takes 10 seconds to see that you're joint 5th in top scorers at the moment.

Seems like you're implying that clean sheets shouldn't be worth so much, but how come GKs aren't dominating the top of the list? I do agree that other players should be given credit for the clean sheet, i swear we used to have that system or am I mistaken?

Thu May 19 2016, 19:00

Where are venoms n wildeys goals...
Its not our fault the other team couldn't field 3 players for the full 14 mins

Thu May 19 2016, 19:07 Message reputation : 25% (4 votes)

mlfaijati wrote:Seems like you're implying that clean sheets shouldn't be worth so much, but how come GKs aren't dominating the top of the list? I do agree that other players should be given credit for the clean sheet, i swear we used to have that system or am I mistaken?

Thing is, I'm not implying clean sheets are worth this much and goals are that munch because neither are quantifiable besides the basic numbers that they represent as in counted. Hence why I said I find the system useless.

Gjonaj wrote:Where are venoms n wildeys goals...
Its not our fault the other team couldn't field 3 players for the full 14 mins

Arbitrary decision, basically

Thu May 19 2016, 19:26

Punish the ones who were innocent
And let the wrongdoer go free

Cmon behave urselves

Thu May 19 2016, 20:10 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

woah didn't expect this to turn into a full blown discussion about metaphysics and empiricism I'm out

Thu May 19 2016, 20:51 Message reputation : 100% (5 votes)

Seb all you do is complain about how others do things, yet do nothing about it yourself? If everyone was like you then nothing would ever be done, be appreciative of what is done in these leagues

Thu May 19 2016, 21:17 Message reputation : 50% (2 votes)

outfield players shud at least get some CS xp cus a CS relies on them more than a GK unless its pub level matches. also if a team switches GK at halftime that GK shud get halftime CS too, me luck and tuntija have rotated GK a lot but we dnt get CS reward even if we are keeping CS for the halves. we had this system last ssn and i didnt see a problem with it. also what yawn sed earlier, the thing of conceding 1 goal and 2 goals and getting points shud only count if ur team won, since if u conceded 2 or 1 and lost it means it was cus u conceded those goals, even if its seen as a low number to concede that is what lost the game.

Thu May 19 2016, 21:26 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

lol mate we don't keep clean sheets wut u on about

Thu May 19 2016, 21:46

my goal against Sheeps

Thu May 19 2016, 21:52

+1 to what B4D said, though I guess it'd be effort to change all the old stats to a new system again - maybe just implement changes like this after this season? Are you using excel for this or is it all just on the forum?

Sat May 21 2016, 12:22 Message reputation : 50% (2 votes)

sugar my goal against sheepss

Tue May 31 2016, 02:18 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

Match Day 17 XP

Renbeaudach, 19xp (3 goals, 1 assist)
Mata, 18xp (2 goals, 2 assists)
SebastiAn, 13xp (1 goal, 2 assists)
Caccapupu, 10xp (only 1 goal conceded)
Iceman, 10xp (only 1 goal conceded)
Wildey, 10xp (2 goals)
rpc, 9xp (1 goal, 1 assist)
Cazorla, 8xp (2 assists)
Ahmed, 5xp (1 goal)
CHE, 5xp (1 goal)
Hannes, 5xp (1 goal)
Holtby, 5xp (1 goal)
ogre, 5xp (1 goal)
Stefan, 5xp (1 goal)
Venom, 5xp (1 goal)
Kirito, 4xp (1 assist)
Twigg, 4xp (1 assist)

Games in hand: Sheepshaggers vs Soccerettes, L8 Unseen vs Cant Score