Re: Season 5 player ratings thread

Sun Jul 03 2016, 17:18 Message reputation : 63% (8 votes)

Player Ratings Ratings

Venom - 5/10 - Not the worst effort but falls into the trap of not using enough variation, and is unduly harsh to a select few such as chuckdog and Splat.

Beninho - 6.5/10 - The assessement of the UK players is by and large pretty good, though I think a bit of knowledge on some of the less familiar foreigners is lacking. Might be a slight bias towards current and former CS players too.

mlfaijati - 7/10 - Hardly complete but it's hard to disagree with most of those he has rated. Perhaps he rates his own players a little too highly, and having Swiezcka higher than Cazorla is a bit of a strange decision, but his set is definitely one of the better ones.

B4D 4SS - 3/10 - The majority of these ratings seem to have been determined by writing a number '7' and then rolling a ten-sided die to see what number he's putting on the end of them. Also clearly hates Swift for some reason.

dale - 5.5/10 - Props for using more of the scale, but if you look at the Socs' and SA ratings in particular you can see a clear difference between the players he knows and those he doesn't.

Hop - 3/10 - Highest and lowest less than 20 points apart on a 100 point scale but still manages to outrageously overrate Sheepshaggers.

Hef - 2/10 - Even less variation, but still manages to screw just about every comparison up. Also, does everyone secretly have it in for Mani?

Swift - 6/10 - Still needs a bit more variation but I don't think they're such a bad stab, even if he adds to the disappointing catalogue of lists that rate Swieczka and Wild above mani. Props also for having the bravery to give Bliz a rating he deserves.

Gjonaj - 7/10 - I like these quite a bit, separates the wheat form the chaff with some clarity of thought but there are a few jarring examples of underrated foreigners like Alekos, Aitor and Ozi.

somalian - 1/10 - Jesus Christ.

vshurvkv - 3.5/10 - Starts off looking fine but then you see stuff like Twigg one point higher than Maddude. Enough said.

Hulk - 4.5/10 - Another set that needs to have the balls to rate some players under 70, but at least most of it's in the right order.

Sun Jul 03 2016, 17:42

mans finally made it onto a list, i knew this day would come

brap

Sun Jul 03 2016, 17:49

@ren - "but at least most of it's in the right order"

there isn't a right order these ratings are based off opinion why should your order be considered 'right' over others like you're a perfect individual with no flaws

fk off faggot

Sun Jul 03 2016, 17:50 Message reputation : 100% (8 votes)

Player ratings ratings rating:

Rénbeaudach - 6.22/10 - Good effort, but slightly lacking deep insight correlation analysis in terms of coherent variation and tangential disposition. However the vicissitude includes amiable complicity in regards of the zephyr gelated mass-induction which is fun.

Sun Jul 03 2016, 17:57 Message reputation : 60% (5 votes)

And having Swiezcka higher than Cazorla is a bit of a strange decision

Even if he adds to the disappointing catalogue of lists that rate Swieczka and Wild above mani.

Then i ask, why are you underrating Swieczka? He is for sure one of the better players in this league now, and he have improved alot since last season. I dont see why its strange that he is rated higher than many others.

And i can for sure see Swiezcka becoming one of the best in this league within a few seasons.

Sun Jul 03 2016, 18:01 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

nero wrote:Player ratings ratings rating:

Rénbeaudach - 6.22/10 - Good effort, but slightly lacking deep insight correlation analysis in terms of coherent variation and tangential disposition. However the vicissitude includes amiable complicity in regards of the zephyr gelated mass-induction which is fun.

10/10

Sun Jul 03 2016, 18:10

@Ren, could you please bestow us with your ratings?

Sun Jul 03 2016, 18:13 Message reputation : 33% (3 votes)

@Ren show more logic u posh mug

Sun Jul 03 2016, 18:27

I am Mr Opinion, the voice of the voiceless.

Cudnt rly disagree with the ratings here but that gjonaj fella probz shud be 9/10.

Sun Jul 03 2016, 18:35 Message reputation : 67% (3 votes)

Sun Jul 03 2016, 18:37 Message reputation : 0% (3 votes)

Hulk wrote:bubblehax

chuck dog -74
deer94 -
Iceman - 76
Jai - 83
Rodwell -
Teraquista - 71
Wildey - 76

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - 70
Cazorla - 78
Eriksen - 76
Éver -
Mata -
ozo jaa -78
Slayer -

L8 Unseen

Swieczka -
A. Tuntija -
Chaos -
FearMe - 77
Kamina -
Zola -

Savage Armada

Alvaro - 71
abi - 80
El JeFE - 82
Hop - 81
Ozi - 80
Splat - 73

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 72
dale12345 - 77
destorm - 79
Nacho Soup - 73
tonMUFC -
vaqq - 75

Can't Score

mlf - 81
dooms - 84
giggs' - 77
Twigg - 74
KnucklezZ - 74
Swift - 77
Alekos - 78

Deja Entendudes

Zizou -
Ahmed -79
eWa# - 84
mirko' - 80
Stefan - 80
UKOriginal - 70

HK Stalingrad

Rén - 75
Aitor -
Element - 80
Redstar - 74
SebastiAn - 78
StringerBell -74
ogre - 80

LGB

Mád - 87
Benin -76
Bliz - 80
Jovetic -
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 78
Diesel - 78

Pelicans

corn -
kolkolk - 75
CHE -
Lumi - 73
Mart -
Nub - 79
Speaks -76

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS -79
Flashin' - 76
Hef - 81
Hulk - 77
Monstah - 82
Ryan McCarthy - 73
shná - 74

Soccerettes

MrP - 75
Ghost - 76
Holtby -
saviola -
Shootstar - 71
Skillem -

are you fucking stupid? L0L

Sun Jul 03 2016, 20:30 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

This thread went so meta it nearly broke my brain.

Sun Jul 03 2016, 20:51

nero wrote: zephyr gelated mass-induction

sounds hot

Sun Jul 03 2016, 21:45 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

VENOM i7 wrote:

Hulk wrote:bubblehax

chuck dog -74
deer94 -
Iceman - 76
Jai - 83
Rodwell -
Teraquista - 71
Wildey - 76

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - 70
Cazorla - 78
Eriksen - 76
Éver -
Mata -
ozo jaa -78
Slayer -

L8 Unseen

Swieczka -
A. Tuntija -
Chaos -
FearMe - 77
Kamina -
Zola -

Savage Armada

Alvaro - 71
abi - 80
El JeFE - 82
Hop - 81
Ozi - 80
Splat - 73

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 72
dale12345 - 77
destorm - 79
Nacho Soup - 73
tonMUFC -
vaqq - 75

Can't Score

mlf - 81
dooms - 84
giggs' - 77
Twigg - 74
KnucklezZ - 74
Swift - 77
Alekos - 78

Deja Entendudes

Zizou -
Ahmed -79
eWa# - 84
mirko' - 80
Stefan - 80
UKOriginal - 70

HK Stalingrad

Rén - 75
Aitor -
Element - 80
Redstar - 74
SebastiAn - 78
StringerBell -74
ogre - 80

LGB

Mád - 87
Benin -76
Bliz - 80
Jovetic -
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 78
Diesel - 78

Pelicans

corn -
kolkolk - 75
CHE -
Lumi - 73
Mart -
Nub - 79
Speaks -76

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS -79
Flashin' - 76
Hef - 81
Hulk - 77
Monstah - 82
Ryan McCarthy - 73
shná - 74

Soccerettes

MrP - 75
Ghost - 76
Holtby -
saviola -
Shootstar - 71
Skillem -

are you fucking stupid? L0L

oops sorry forgot

Free agents

Ven - 51
Somalian 75
Somalian 2 - 76

Sun Jul 03 2016, 22:13

safe hulk, THESE LOT UNDERRATE ME STILL

Mon Jul 04 2016, 00:11

I am new to this league so i don't know alot of these ppl. But i'll give my ratings out of what i've seen in pubs and fs

bubblehax

chuckdog - 74
deer94 - ?
Iceman - 76
Jai - 82
Rodwell - ?
Teraquista - 74
Wildey - 76

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - ?
Cazorla - ?
Eriksen - ?
Éver - ?
Mata - ?
ozo jaa - 80
Slayer - ?

L8 Unseen

Swieczka - ?
A. Tuntija - 77
Chaos - 74
FearMe - 79
Kamina - ?
Zola - ?

Savage Armada

Alvaro - 75
abi - 81
El JeFE - 79
Hop - 80
Ozi - 79
Splat - 75

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 75
dale12345 - 76
destorm - ?
Nacho Soup - 78
tonMUFC - 67
vaqq - ?

Can't Score

mlf - 78
dooms - ?
giggs' - ?
Twigg - 77
KnucklezZ - 74
Swift - 82
Alekos - 82

Deja Entendudes

Zizou - ?
Ahmed - 80
eWa# - 82
mirko' - 82
Stefan - 83
UKOriginal - 71

HK Stalingrad (dont know these at all ;s)

Rén - ?
Aitor - ?
Element - ?
Redstar - ?
SebastiAn - ?
StringerBell- ?
ogre - ?

LGB

Mád - ?
Beninho - ?
Bliz - 79
Jovetic - 77
Nebraska/apple - ?
Q - 80
Diesel - 78

Pelicans

corn - ?
kolkolk - ?
CHE - 78
Lumi - 74
Mart - 69
Nub - 80
Speaks - 76

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS - 79
Flashin' - not rating myself but probs under 75
Hef - 81
Hulk - 77
Monstah - 82
Ryan McCarthy - 72
shná - 76

Soccerettes

MrP - 76
Ghost - 77
Holtby - 79
saviola - ?
Shootstar - 73
Skillem - ?

Dont Judge me pls ^^ this is only what i've seen, i could be horribly wrong Smile

Mon Jul 04 2016, 04:00

nero wrote:Player ratings ratings rating:

Rénbeaudach - 6.22/10 - Good effort, but slightly lacking deep insight correlation analysis in terms of coherent variation and tangential disposition. However the vicissitude includes amiable complicity in regards of the zephyr gelated mass-induction which is fun.

I shall not argue against it from the supposed impossibility of infinite succession, barely and absolutely considered in itself; for a reason which shall be mentioned hereafter: but if we consider such an infinite progression, as one entire endless series of beings can have no cause from without, of its existence; because in it are supposed to be included all things that are or ever were in the universe: and ’tis plain it can have no reason within itself, of its existence; because no one being in this infinite succession is supposed to be self-existent or necessary (which is the only ground or reason of existence of any thing, that can be imagined within the thing itself, as with presently more fully appear), but every one dependent on the foregoing: and where no part is necessary; ’tis manifest the whole cannot be necessary; absolute necessity of existence, not being an outward, relative, and accidental determination; but an inward and essential property of the nature of the thing which so exists.

Mon Jul 04 2016, 05:45

Since when were you so philosophical Stefan?

Mon Jul 04 2016, 11:41 Message reputation : 67% (3 votes)

bubblehax

chuckdog -78
deer94 -75
Iceman -74
Jai -85
Rodwell -77
Teraquista - 65
Wildey -76

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - 74
Cazorla - 72
Eriksen -
Éver -
Mata - 80
ozo jaa -
Slayer -

L8 Unseen

Swieczka - 77
A. Tuntija - 79
Chaos -
FearMe -
Kamina - 81
Zola - 80

Savage Armada

Alvaro - 73
abi - 82
El JeFE -
Hop - 80
Ozi - 75
Splat - 73

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 73
dale12345 - 77
destorm - 77
Nacho Soup - 75
tonMUFC -
vaqq -

Can't Score

mlf - 82
dooms - 70
giggs' - 78
Twigg - 77
KnucklezZ - 73
Swift - 79
Alekos - 83

Deja Entendudes

Zizou - 76
Ahmed - 78
eWa# -
mirko' -
Stefan - 81
UKOriginal - 65

HK Stalingrad

Rén - 79
Aitor -
Element -
Redstar -
SebastiAn - 80
StringerBell - 74
ogre - 83

LGB

Mád - 88
Beninho - 79
Bliz - 74
Jovetic - 72
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 76
Diesel - 75

Pelicans

corn - 76
kolkolk -
CHE - 73
Lumi - 68
Mart -
Nub - 77
Speaks - 75

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS - 78
Flashin' - 75
Hef - 74
Hulk - 72
Monstah - 76
Ryan McCarthy - 71
shná -

Soccerettes

MrP - 76
Ghost - 73
Holtby - 75
saviola - 79
Shootstar -
Skillem - 74

dunno how accurate mine are cus i haven't really been following hax for a while, but there we go

Mon Jul 04 2016, 14:38

Sтeғαn wrote:

nero wrote:Player ratings ratings rating:

Rénbeaudach - 6.22/10 - Good effort, but slightly lacking deep insight correlation analysis in terms of coherent variation and tangential disposition. However the vicissitude includes amiable complicity in regards of the zephyr gelated mass-induction which is fun.

I shall not argue against it from the supposed impossibility of infinite succession, barely and absolutely considered in itself; for a reason which shall be mentioned hereafter: but if we consider such an infinite progression, as one entire endless series of beings can have no cause from without, of its existence; because in it are supposed to be included all things that are or ever were in the universe: and ’tis plain it can have no reason within itself, of its existence; because no one being in this infinite succession is supposed to be self-existent or necessary (which is the only ground or reason of existence of any thing, that can be imagined within the thing itself, as with presently more fully appear), but every one dependent on the foregoing: and where no part is necessary; ’tis manifest the whole cannot be necessary; absolute necessity of existence, not being an outward, relative, and accidental determination; but an inward and essential property of the nature of the thing which so exists.

wot :?:

Mon Jul 04 2016, 15:49

Jai. wrote:

LGB

Mád - 88
Beninho - 79
Bliz - 74
Jovetic - 72
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 76
Diesel - 75

LOL @ 74

Mon Jul 04 2016, 17:07 Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)

Bliz wrote:

Jai. wrote:

LGB

Mád - 88
Beninho - 79
Bliz - 74
Jovetic - 72
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 76
Diesel - 75

LOL @ 74

prove me wrong bro alien

Tue Jul 05 2016, 00:00 Message reputation : 0% (1 vote)

bubblehax

chuckdog - 73
deer94 - 70
Iceman - 74
Jai - 84
Rodwell - 78
Teraquista - 67
Wildey - 75

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - 73
Cazorla - 73
Eriksen - 71
Éver - 75
Mata - 84
ozo jaa - 81
Slayer -

L8 Unseen

Swieczka - 74
A. Tuntija - 75
Chaos -
FearMe - 74
Kamina - 73
Zola - 75

Savage Armada

Alvaro - 67
abi - 81
El JeFE - 73
Hop - 72
Ozi - 73
Splat - 75
floss - 68

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 67
dale12345 - 71
destorm - 69
Nacho Soup - 73
tonMUFC - 62
vaqq - 73

Can't Score

mlf - 82
dooms -
giggs' - 74
Twigg - 74
KnucklezZ - 71
Swift - 77
Alekos - 80

Deja Entendudes

Zizou - 71
Ahmed - 74
eWa# - 74
mirko' - 72
Stefan - 76
UKOriginal - 65

HK Stalingrad

Rén - 73
Aitor - 77
Element - 78
Redstar - 66
SebastiAn - 76
StringerBell - 71
ogre - 77

LGB

Mád - 82
Beninho - 72
Bliz - 80
Jovetic -
Nebraska/apple - 73
Q - 72
Diesel - 72

Pelicans

corn -
kolkolk - 72
CHE - 75
Lumi - 73
Mart - 68
Nub - 74
Speaks - 72

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS - 77
Flashin' - 74
Hef - 77
Hulk - 75
Monstah - 80
Ryan McCarthy - 69
shná - 76

Soccerettes

MrP - 73
Ghost - 74
Holtby - 83
saviola - 75
Shootstar - 69
Skillem - 75

Tue Jul 05 2016, 00:57

bubblehax

chuckdog - 78
deer94 - 75
Iceman - 76
Jai - 83
Rodwell - 80
Teraquista - R.I.P (68)
Alison - 92
Wildey - 12

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - 76
Cazorla - 79
Eriksen - 79
Éver - ?
Mata - 83
ozo jaa - 80
Slayer - ?

L8 Unseen

Swieczka - 78
A. Tuntija - 79
Chaos - ?
FearMe - 77
Kamina - 79
Zola - 78

Savage Armada

Alvaro - 70
abi - 82
El JeFE - 80
Hop - 79
Ozi - 77
Splat - 75

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 72
dale12345 - 77
destorm - 79
Nacho Soup - ?
tonMUFC - 66
vaqq - 76

Can't Score

mlf - 82
dooms - ?
giggs' - 79
Twigg - 77
KnucklezZ - 76
Swift - 80
Alekos - 81

Deja Entendudes

Zizou - 76
Ahmed - 80
eWa# - 79
mirko' - 80
Stefan - 82
UKOriginal - 73

HK Stalingrad

Rén - 76
Aitor - 79
Element - 81
Redstar - ?
SebastiAn - 78
StringerBell - 75
ogre - 83

LGB

Mád - 87
Beninho - 78
Bliz - 80
Jovetic - 75
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 79
Diesel - 75

Pelicans

corn - 76
kolkolk - 75
CHE - 77
Lumi - 72
Mart - 69
Nub - 77
Speaks - 78

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS - 78
Flashin' - 74
Hef - 79
Hulk - 78
Monstah - 80
Ryan McCarthy - 70
shná - 77

Soccerettes

MrP - 75
Ghost - 76
Holtby - 78
saviola - 77
Shootstar - 74
Skillem - 71

Free Agents

Venom - 74

Tue Jul 05 2016, 01:18

bubblehax

chuckdog - 74
deer94 - 72
Iceman - 72
Jai - 83
Rodwell - 80
Teraquista - 68
Wildey - 79

Guard Dogs

CM Punk - 77
Cazorla - 78
Eriksen - 80
Éver - /
Mata - 81
ozo jaa - 80
Slayer - doesn't play haxball

L8 Unseen

Swieczka - 74
A. Tuntija - 79
Chaos - /
FearMe - 77
Kamina - 77
Zola - 79

Savage Armada

Alvaro - /
abi - 81
El JeFE - /
Hop - 79
Ozi - 77
Splat - 73

The Flying Peacocks

Jds - 68
dale12345 - 74
destorm - 78
Nacho Soup - 76
tonMUFC - /
vaqq - 75

Can't Score

mlf - 83
dooms - / not seen lately
giggs' - 77
Twigg - 77
KnucklezZ - / not seen lately
Swift - 80
Alekos - 82

Deja Entendudes

Zizou - 76
Ahmed - 79
eWa# - 82
mirko' - 82
Stefan - 82
UKOriginal - doesn't play haxball

HK Stalingrad

Rén - 77
Aitor - 79
Element - 81
Redstar - /
SebastiAn - 78
StringerBell - 75
ogre - 82

LGB

Mád - 84
Beninho - 78
Bliz - 80
Jovetic - 78
Nebraska/apple - 78
Q - 76
Diesel - 78

Pelicans

corn - 74
kolkolk - /
CHE - 77
Lumi - 74
Mart - 72
Nub - 79
Speaks - 78

Sheepshaggers

B4D 4SS - 78
Flashin' - 79
Hef - 79
Hulk - 78
Monstah - 79
Ryan McCarthy - 77
shná - 76

Soccerettes

MrP - 78
Ghost - 77
Holtby - 79
saviola - 78
Shootstar - 75
Skillem - 77