rules discussion
+9
Mád
Rénbeaudach
B4D 4SS
The Doctor
Zizou
Sugar Ray
Ghost
corn
mlfaijati
13 posters
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
- mlfaijatiAdministrator
- Posts : 642
Reputation : 190
Status :Online Offline
rules discussion
Thu Mar 17 2016, 23:16
1) 5 wildcards seems a bit too many tbh, 3 or 4 is sufficient
2) The randomised order for new teams should be done in a snake format for each round, so for example:
Round 1:
New Team 1
New Team 2
New Team 3
Rest of Order
Round 2:
New Team 3
New Team 2
New Team 1
Rest of Order
etc
3) Also the Cup doesn't really need to be 7 mins a half as it's knockout, it being a different length to league matches is nice flavour as well
2) The randomised order for new teams should be done in a snake format for each round, so for example:
Round 1:
New Team 1
New Team 2
New Team 3
Rest of Order
Round 2:
New Team 3
New Team 2
New Team 1
Rest of Order
etc
3) Also the Cup doesn't really need to be 7 mins a half as it's knockout, it being a different length to league matches is nice flavour as well
- cornAdministrator
- Posts : 1389
Reputation : 141
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Thu Mar 17 2016, 23:22
if others agree, I will make the necessary changes.
- mlfaijatiAdministrator
- Posts : 642
Reputation : 190
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Fri Mar 18 2016, 14:17
maybe put up polls for each bullet point? I'd say the 2nd one is something which is common sense/what you were intending anyway, the other 2 being my opinions.
- GhostAdministrator
- Posts : 436
Reputation : 167
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 19:26
I think the half time needs to be talked about. We've been fsing 7 minute halves and it's just too long. 6 might be just about the right length.
- Sugar RaySuperman
- Posts : 897
Reputation : -45
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 19:30
Too many wildcards will just encourage people to use them more and agree with ghost but silly corn had to go and make a public vote
- GuestGuest
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 19:48
Typical for the grandad to say that but sugar u unfit oompa loompa.
Ill give u sum advice....Salad tastes nice
Ill give u sum advice....Salad tastes nice
- Sugar RaySuperman
- Posts : 897
Reputation : -45
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 19:50
Should do vote again with 6 minute option
- GuestGuest
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 20:06
Ghost wrote:I think the half time needs to be talked about. We've been fsing 7 minute halves and it's just too long. 6 might be just about the right length.
yeah I agree.
- mlfaijatiAdministrator
- Posts : 642
Reputation : 190
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 20:55
i'd be for 6 mins, put up a poll for 6 or 7, as i think we can all agree 5 is too short, if not in fs then in regulation matches
- ZizouEnergetic
- Posts : 143
Reputation : 52
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 21:40
7 min is simple too long.
- The DoctorSmooth Operator
- Posts : 407
Reputation : -89
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 21:43
7 mins should be long enough to distinguish between the better teams.
Why do you all want 6 mins?
There is no difference, most games are usually over by the 6 minute mark.
Why do you all want 6 mins?
There is no difference, most games are usually over by the 6 minute mark.
- mlfaijatiAdministrator
- Posts : 642
Reputation : 190
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Mon Mar 28 2016, 23:00
back in my day we used to just ban doctor from forums
also just to play devil's advocate has anyone actually tried 6 min halves?
also just to play devil's advocate has anyone actually tried 6 min halves?
- B4D 4SSSuperman
- Posts : 728
Reputation : -124
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 00:41
10min halves in big ez felt good, much better than 5 so i wud vote 7 again if it was polled. its only 2 matches a week anyway may as well have as much match time as possible
- cornAdministrator
- Posts : 1389
Reputation : 141
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 00:42
i'll give it a few days and if people still want 6 ill remake the poll.
- The DoctorSmooth Operator
- Posts : 407
Reputation : -89
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 01:04
Not even one match day has been played yet and already a change is being made
I blame the new addition to the admin team.
I blame the new addition to the admin team.
- cornAdministrator
- Posts : 1389
Reputation : 141
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 01:10
The Doctor wrote:Not even one match day has been played yet and already a change is being made
I blame the new addition to the admin team.
i'll give it a few days and if people still want 6 ill remake the poll.
- The DoctorSmooth Operator
- Posts : 407
Reputation : -89
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 03:18
What was the point of the initial poll if it was going to be redone? hhhhhcorn wrote:The Doctor wrote:Not even one match day has been played yet and already a change is being made
I blame the new addition to the admin team.
i'll give it a few days and if people still want 6 ill remake the poll.
- cornAdministrator
- Posts : 1389
Reputation : 141
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 03:26
People were complaining that 5 minutes was too short. I put up the poll, 7 was the winner. There may or may not be a new poll. It could just be a case of 'change' and learning to cope with longer games, as people need to adjust to them. Voting based on your imitial opinion is never a good idea.
Let's see what people think in the next few days, after more 7 min fses and the pre season cup.
Let's see what people think in the next few days, after more 7 min fses and the pre season cup.
- The DoctorSmooth Operator
- Posts : 407
Reputation : -89
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 03:32
6 minutes and 7 minutes, lmao there is literally no difference.
Can't believe we need to decide whether we play an extra minute or not. This is what happens when players get too much of a say, they start to question everything.
With this change I can see some captain's using the "oh we put it as 7 minutes by accident so let's re the game" if they lose.
Let the people decide though, as you say.
Can't believe we need to decide whether we play an extra minute or not. This is what happens when players get too much of a say, they start to question everything.
With this change I can see some captain's using the "oh we put it as 7 minutes by accident so let's re the game" if they lose.
Let the people decide though, as you say.
- RénbeaudachAdministrator
- Posts : 689
Reputation : 152
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 04:05
I stayed up till 4 to neg every single one of doc's replies and I am not ashamed in the slightest.
- The DoctorSmooth Operator
- Posts : 407
Reputation : -89
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 05:40
Ah you must've been sleeping during the day when I was looking to play you in the 1v1 tourny. That explains how you have managed to stay up so late.Rénbeaudach wrote:I stayed up till 4 to neg every single one of doc's replies and I am not ashamed in the slightest.
Negs count towards nothing on this forum as it's anonymous and without limit.
- mlfaijatiAdministrator
- Posts : 642
Reputation : 190
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 12:03
i mean this could simply be solved by teams just agreeing to do 5 mins a half in fs, but maybe 6 mins is the optimal game time for 3v3 in a league context
- GhostAdministrator
- Posts : 436
Reputation : 167
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 13:14
We played 6 minute halves in FS last night. It was a lot better than playing 7 minutes.
While it's only a minute in real time, it still makes a massive difference while playing the game. This is PER HALF, too. Playing 7 minute halves makes the game 4 minutes longer than 5 minute halves. It's too much for 3v3 and it genuinely ruins the flow of the match, for me.
While it's only a minute in real time, it still makes a massive difference while playing the game. This is PER HALF, too. Playing 7 minute halves makes the game 4 minutes longer than 5 minute halves. It's too much for 3v3 and it genuinely ruins the flow of the match, for me.
- MádForum Bangout
- Posts : 352
Reputation : 38
Status :Online Offline
Re: rules discussion
Tue Mar 29 2016, 19:27
1x11.6 please, no more bullshittery
#makehaxgr8again
#maddudeforadmin
#makehaxgr8again
#maddudeforadmin
Page 1 of 2 • 1, 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|